WIDEN Legal Latvia sworn attorney Lāsma Dunovska and senior lawyer Madara Jozēna Fabrina have obtained two favourable judgments from the Riga District Court, representing an air carrier in proceedings on passenger claims based on Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council. In both cases the court dismissed the claims in full and, in addition, awarded legal costs against the claimants in favour of WIDEN Legal Latvia’s client, the air carrier. In one of the cases the claim was brought by the passenger himself, while in the other it was brought by a business to which the passenger’s right of claim had been assigned.
Preclusive time limit and the obligation to prove non-pecuniary damage
In the first case, the court held that claims against an air carrier arising from Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council are subject to the special two-year time limit laid down in Section 109 of the Law “On Aviation”, excluding the application of the general ten-year limitation period under the Civil Law. The court stressed that this time limit is preclusive, i.e. an extinguishing time limit of substantive law, the purpose of which is to ensure legal certainty in the aviation sector. The court also stated that the running of this time limit is interrupted neither by the passenger’s correspondence with the carrier nor by the use of out-of-court dispute resolution procedures. Submitting a complaint to the carrier is a mandatory pretrial condition for exercising the right to bring an action before the court, not a ground for interrupting the limitation period.
The court agreed with WIDEN Legal Latvia’s arguments on the preconditions for compensation of non-pecuniary damage, stressing that the existence of non-pecuniary damage in such cases is not presumed and the passenger must prove that the flight delay caused not only a loss of time but also another kind of harm. The court held that ordinary inconvenience or disappointment caused by a flight delay is not a sufficient ground for compensation of non-pecuniary damage under Section 1635 of the Civil Law in itself, given that Regulation No 261/2004 provides for standardised compensation for certain flight disruptions.
Extraordinary circumstances and exemption from paying compensation
In the second case, the claim was dismissed because the proceedings established that the exemption from paying compensation provided for in Article 5(3) of Regulation No 261/2004 applied. This case highlights that Regulation No 261/2004 not only protects passengers’ right to receive compensation but also clearly sets out the cases in which an air carrier may be released from the obligation to pay compensation, provided the relevant preconditions are met.
Legal precision in aviation disputes
Both judgments demonstrate how essential the precise application of Regulation No 261/2004 and the national legal framework is in disputes concerning passenger rights. They highlight the importance of statutory time limits and the pre-trial procedure, as well as the burden of proof on the claimant, the passenger. At the same time, they confirm the air carrier’s right to rely on extraordinary circumstances where the preconditions for exemption from paying compensation laid down in the legislation are met.
The WIDEN Legal Latvia team continues to provide legal assistance to air carriers, defending their interests in disputes concerning passenger rights and the application of Regulation No 261/2004.





